drochon9_WILLIAM WESTAFP via Getty Images_covidconspiracy

عن الحرية والتآمر والتلقيح

Jul 2, 2021 Hugo Drochon

باريس - على الرغم من أن دولاً مثل إسرائيل والمملكة المتحدة والولايات المتحدة قد حققت أداءً جيدًا بشكل خاص في توزيع لقاحات كوفيد 19 في أسرع وقت ممكن، إلا أن التردد بشأن استخدام اللقاحات لا يزال يُشكل عقبة خطيرة. وفي الولايات المتحدة، تسبب هذا التردد بالفعل في تعطيل هدف الرئيس جو بايدن بتلقيح 70٪ من سكان الولايات المتحدة مرة واحدة على الأقل قبل 4 يوليو / تموز الجاري.

وفي استطلاع أجرته شبكة سي إن إن في شهر أبريل / نيسان، قال حوالي 26٪ من الأمريكيين الذين شملهم الاستطلاع أنهم لا ينوون تلقي التطعيم على الإطلاق. تُعد هذه مشكلة كبيرة، حيث يُعد التلقيح شبه الشامل الطريقة الوحيدة الموثوقة للقضاء على الجائحة. وإذا افترضنا، على سبيل المثال، أن متغيرات فيروس كورونا، والتي تُعد مُعدية مثل الحصبة، أصبحت سائدة، فإن تحقيق مناعة القطيع قد يتطلب أن يكون 94 ٪ من السكان مُحصّنين.

وفي ظل هذه الظروف، قد يميل صُناع السياسات إلى محاولة قمع التردد بشأن استخدام اللقاح - المدفوع بنظريات المؤامرة إلى حد كبير. بالنسبة للمؤمنين بعدم صحة اللقاحات، فإن الخطر الحقيقي لا يتمثل في فيروس كوفيد 19، ولكن في أن بيل جيتس يستخدم اللقاحات لزرع رقائق إلكترونية دقيقة في أدمغتنا.

To continue reading, register now.

As a registered user, you can enjoy more PS content every month – for free.

Subscribe now for unlimited access to everything PS has to offer.

Already have an account? Log in

Support High-Quality Commentary

For more than 25 years, Project Syndicate has been guided by a simple credo: All people deserve access to a broad range of views by the world's foremost leaders and thinkers on the issues, events, and forces shaping their lives. At a time of unprecedented uncertainty, that mission is more important than ever – and we remain committed to fulfilling it.

But there is no doubt that we, like so many other media organizations nowadays, are under growing strain. If you are in a position to support us, please subscribe now.

As a subscriber, you will enjoy unlimited access to our On Point suite of long reads, book reviews, and insider interviews; Big Picture topical collections; Say More contributor interviews; Opinion Has It podcast features; The Year Ahead magazine, the full PS archive, and much more. You will also directly support our mission of delivering the highest-quality commentary on the world's most pressing issues to as wide an audience as possible.

By helping us to build a truly open world of ideas, every PS subscriber makes a real difference. Thank you.

Subscribe Now

new comment has been posted. new comments have been posted.

0 Comments on this paragraph, 6 Comments on this article

Charles Jones Oct 21, 2021

The "Cabal" is not a small group. It's small in proportion only. We understand and fully agree that humanity has some changes to make but under no circumstance will those changes diminish individual liberties. How do you expect us to trust media platforms and allegedly elected or self appointed authorities when we have watched them blatantly lie for years? Add to that the U.N., politicians, civil servants and corporations using an integrated systems approach to manipulate pressures on the masses AND falling back on threats and force if needed and the jig is up. We refuse. The "for the sake of public safety"argument for censorship is ludicrous. Challenge helps define evolution. Humanity needs to be able to discern truth and relevance, not be informed what to think.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Denise Wright Aug 4, 2021

On the force part of the article. Just how do the folks that espouse this line of thought plan to accomplish that force. What will they do when they encounter individuals with the mindset and the means to resist said force to the death. These folks will not go alone.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
j. von Hettlingen Jul 4, 2021

Hugo Drochon says the US, despite being one of the world’s leading countries in vaccine rollout, hesitancy has derailed Biden’s goal of getting 70% of adults partly vaccinated by July 4. So far just around 67% of adults had received at least one shot. Since the vaccination rate has plummeted from its peak in April, the country’s progress as a whole has slowed significantly, with only about one million doses being administered each week on average.
According to a CNN poll in April, “about 26% of US respondents said they do not intend to get vaccinated at all. That is a big problem, given that near-universal vaccination is the only reliable way to end the pandemic.” The rapid spread of the highly contagious Delta variant has also raised concerns among health officials, who fear that new outbreaks could emerge in parts of the country where vaccination rates have been comparatively low, and that the variant could mutate in ways that leave even vaccinated Americans vulnerable.
Since vaccine hesitancy has posed a major threat to achieving herd immunity, health authorities might be tempted to crack down on conspiracy theories and misinformation about Covid-19 and vaccines, that stoke fear and hesitancy. Yet the author says conspiracy theories are “just another form of free speech…. In his classic defense of that principle, On Liberty, John Stuart Mill offers two arguments: those who hold erroneous beliefs are more likely to abandon them in a free exchange of ideas, while vigorously contesting a true belief prevents it from becoming an unexamined prejudice or dogma.”
Authorities face the dilemma about what to do with conspiracy theorists, who “genuinely believe that a small secret group of people – a cabal – controls the world.” The author asks whether we should “stifle conspiracy theorists in the interest of facilitating a rational exchange of ideas… Mill, who opposed all forms of censorship, argued that such a public intervention is justified only on the basis of the ‘harm principle.’" In On Liberty, Mill famously said “the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others.”
While sceptcs should be allowed to voice their dissent and rail against Covid-19 vaccines, elected politicians worry that anti-vaccine sentiment could threaten their country’s recovery from the pandemic. While some conspiracy theories do not “hurt anyone, though otherwise harmless conspiracy theories can of course encourage harmful acts. For example, the belief that 5G technologies help to propagate COVID-19 has led people in the UK to burn down cell towers.”
History is littered with violent acts linked to conspiracy theories. Since the early Middle Ages, the world saw an ancient form of anti-Semitism that blamed Jews for spreading illnesses and other tragedies etc. Conspiracy theorists always end up pointing fingers at Jews, calling them “Rothschild Zionists.” The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,” notorious Czarist secret police fabrication” printed in 1903, accused Jews and Freemasons of having made plans to disrupt Christian civilization and erect a world state under their joint rule. Today, George Soros is the far-right’s useful punching bag.
Even the violent January 6 attack on Capitol was a result of a conspiracy theory spread by QAnon, “which holds that Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, and Soros are part of a Satanist, pedophilic child sex-trafficking ring,” with the debunked conspiracy theory going viral during the 2016 presidential election campaign. While little progress had bee made since then, the author says, “the US has a number of legal measures designed to encompass the negative effects of conspiracy theories, such as ‘breach of peace’ ordinances and laws against disorderly conduct or ‘hate speech.’”
Unlike in the US, common sense seems to prevail: “Evidence from the UK suggests that as more people get vaccinated, vaccine hesitancy declines. The UK and US both started with similar levels of 'anti-vax' sentiment last summer, but such views have plummeted in the UK, and the country is now outpacing the US in vaccinations. This suggests that as more people get vaccinated and see that everything is okay, others may be more likely to follow suit.”
The author says, “the best way to create this virtuous cycle is not to censor conspiracy theories but rather to vaccinate more people and spread the message that vaccines are indeed safe and effective. Seeking to prevent false beliefs from being aired simply gives ammunition to those claiming that the state is out to get them.”
According to Mill, “all beliefs are either wholly false, partly true, or wholly true. In the case of conspiracy theories, we should remember that many are often based on some grain of truth, or at least on a legitimate impulse to challenge the elite consensus. No, Gates doesn’t want to control our minds with microchips; but it is perfectly reasonable to worry that today’s tech giants have too much influence over the way we think. Exploring these nuances is what Mill meant when he advocated for the vigorous public contestation of true beliefs. Though we might beat the pandemic eventually, the battle for critical thinking will go on.”
Nevertheless it is essential to provide the public with accurate data and information to debunk their false beliefs. In times of crisis good leadership is urgently required to win people's trust and help them weather the storm.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
M M Jul 3, 2021

The best was Merkel yesterday! She said “there is no problem in using and mixing multiple vaccines!!!! Seriously, but seriously….are we sitting in a bar on a Caribbean island waiting to be served multi-coloured, mixed alcoholic and “spirit ..ual” beverages? Who knows, these cocktails and cocktail bars may be much more effective against COVID-19 than all the available so-called vaccines combined.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Paul Martin Jul 2, 2021

The vaccine hesitancy is not based on conspiracy theories but on hard facts about the horrendous number of death and side effects due to the vaccine, and the undisputable reality that this is actually not a "vaccine" but an experimental gene therapy which is so unsafe that the pharmaceutical labs have demanded, and obtained, from governments a full waiver of liability for the side effects.

Who wants to take a chance with his own life if the producer of the substance does not believe it is safe?

Please also acknowledge the fact that the government of Denmark banned Astra-Zeneca vaccine completely due to its high lethal danger. This is no conspiracy theory. The government of Denmark is not made of conspiracy theorists.

Also, it is no conspiracy theory to notice the fact that governments have prohibited treatments of the disease proven effective such as Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquin. Why this? Quite obviously the only reason can be conflicts of interests of public health officers who are bought by the pharmaceutical industry. Believing this, as I do, is it being a conspiracy theorist ? If it is, I am one, and we are many.

Indeed, prohibiting by state power an effective treatment is a state crime. When governments are committing a crime just to promote vaccination, there must be something fishy with the vaccination.

Also, there is too much compelling evidence that the pro vaccine propaganda is a lie, aiming at finding an excuse for world government and global population control by vaccine passport and QR codes, which is forced upon us by lies and blackmail. Many are understanding this, there is no wonder if there is vaccine hesitancy.

This is no conspiracy theory but mere instinct of survival in front of a criminal campaign of public poisoning.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
M M Jul 2, 2021

COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants)

This invisible and silent killer, unprecedented in its speed, scale and spread, was it engineered? Was it a pure coincidence? Was it an evolution of our modern life styles and juvenile leadership or the result of complacent behaviour and failed policies?
Why does COVID-19 attack and inhibit predominately humans, while other species are immune from it? Is it because these species have no right to vote and no right to participate in elections and no point in spying on them (Track and Trace, multiple colour passports and so on)?

Is COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants), the smoking gun or the finger that pulled the trigger? All these questions and many more, have remained with no official answer, nearly two years since this deadly disease was officially acknowledged.

The scientists, and to some extent, were silenced and are still under tremendous constraints, unable to disclose the truth. It is the elected and self-centred officials who decided to take centre stage and fight COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants) with the use of camera lenses and through the media.
COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants) evolved at an even faster speed from being a physical killer to becoming the object of financial greed, opportunism, cronyism, adultery and all other forms of despicable human behaviour.

There must be no doubt, that the main culprits are the human species. If humans were not the cause of COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants), why did these same humans introduce erratic policies and are still living in denial about the true existence of this deadly disease and its long term effect on humanity and the planet?

When a fire erupts, the first reaction would be to contain it by co-ordinating all efforts, thereby limiting its spread, and then putting it down using all possible and available means (qualified and well trained personnel, air transport, sea water, fluids, etc.). In the case of COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants), the juvenile leadership decided to use the media and the administrative, economic and financial means that are at their disposal to fight it, as if COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants) can read and write and come from a certain sexual orientation or ethnic background.

The very sad truth is that COVID-19 (and its wide and constantly evolving range of variants) is here to stay, despite the best efforts of the very few. Unless there is a true will by the policy makers and a responsible behaviour by the population at large to tackle this deadly disease, in a serious and professional manner, humanity can only be heading towards a slow but certain path of extinction.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.

https://prosyn.org/C2DHTdfar

عن الحرية والتآمر والتلقيح

Support High-Quality Commentary

New Comment

Email this piece to a friend

Contact us

Log in/Register

عن الحرية والتآمر والتلقيح

Support High-Quality Commentary

Edit Newsletter Preferences

Set up Notification